9 Seed Starting Tips I Wish I Knew Sooner: Lessons from My Own Garden

This site contains affiliate links, view the disclaimer page for more information.

Every spring, I get excited about seed starting. There’s something so rewarding about watching tiny sprouts emerge, knowing I played a part in bringing them to life. But let me tell you- seed starting is not always as simple as it looks on social media. Over the years, I’ve learned a lot through trial and error, asking countless questions, and tweaking my process to avoid common mistakes.

If you are new to seed starting or struggling with it, this post is for you. These are the lessons I wish I had known sooner- things I’ve figured out the hard way, plus answers to questions I’ve personally asked along the way.

1. Can You Overwater Seed Trays? (Yes, and Here’s How to Avoid It)

One of my biggest mistakes early on was keeping my seed trays way too wet. I assumed more moisture meant better germination, but instead, I ended up with soggy soil and weak seedlings.

Lesson learned: The soil should be damp, not soaked. If you see standing water or notice algae or mold forming, it’s too wet. Bottom watering (pouring water into the tray instead of directly onto the soil) helps prevent over saturation. Also, if your humidity domes are dripping with condensation, it’s a sign to vent them or remove them once the seeds sprout.

2. Are Heat Mats Necessary? (Yes, But With Limits)

I used to think heat mats were optional, but once I started using them, my germination rates improved dramatically. That said, I also learned the hard way that keeping the heat mats on too long can cause problems.

Lesson learned: Heat mats are great for germination, but once the seeds sprout, they don’t need as much warmth. Keeping them too hot can lead to leggy growth. As soon as most of my seeds have germinated, I either turn off the heat mat or move the seedlings to a cooler area.

3. Do I Really Need Grow Lights? (Yes, Unless You Have a South-Facing Greenhouse Window- and even then I would still say yes)

If you have ever started seeds on a sunny windowsill only to end up with weak, stretched-out seedlings, you’re not alone. I tried this my first year and was so frustrated when my plants grew tall and spindly instead of strong and compact.

Lesson learned: Most seedlings need 12-16 hours of light per day, and even a bright window usually isn’t enough. Grow lights make a huge difference. Position them close to the seedlings (about 2-4 inches above) and raise them as the plants grow. If your seedlings look long and weak, they’re probably stretching for light- lower your grow light or increase the brightness.

4. When Should I Take the Humidity Dome Off?

Here the seeds have started to sprout. I will keep humidity domes on for a few more days but keep the top vented until they all have sprouted.

I used to leave my humidity domes on for too long because I thought seedlings needed that extra moisture. What actually happened? Mold started growing on the soil, and some of my seedlings collapsed from damping off (a fungal disease that attacks young plants).

Lesson learned: As soon as you see the first seedlings popping up, crack open the dome. Once the majority have sprouted, remove it completely. This prevents excessive moisture buildup and gives your plants the airflow they need to grow strong.

5. Why Are My Seedlings Falling Over?

Nothing is more heartbreaking than watching your little sprouts topple over and die. I’ve had this happen when I wasn’t paying attention to airflow, light, and moisture levels.

Lesson learned: The three biggest culprits for weak, floppy seedlings are:

Not enough light: Use strong grow lights placed close to the seedlings.
Too much water: Avoid soggy soil and let the top dry slightly between waterings.
Lack of airflow: A small fan set on low will help strengthen the stems and prevent mold.

6. Do I Really Need to Harden Off Seedlings? (Yes, or They Will Die Outside)

I’ll admit it- my second year I skipped the hardening-off process because I was impatient. I had healthy seedlings indoors, and I figured they would be fine going straight into the garden. Well, they weren’t. Within a day, the sun and wind had fried them.

Lesson learned: Seedlings grown indoors need time to adjust to outdoor conditions. Start by placing them outside for an hour or two in a shady spot, gradually increasing their time in the sun over a week or so. This small step makes a huge difference in their survival rate.

7. What’s the Best Way to Prevent Leggy Seedlings?

This was one of my top frustrations when I first started growing from seed. My plants would get tall, thin, and weak instead of bushy and strong.

Lesson learned: The key to preventing leggy seedlings is light, airflow, and temperature control:

Strong grow lights close to the plants keep them from stretching.
A small fan helps simulate outdoor conditions and encourages sturdy stems.
Keeping temps slightly cooler (especially at night) slows down excessive growth.

If your seedlings are already leggy, you can sometimes fix them by gently repotting them deeper in the soil to support their stems.

8. What Seed-Starting Supplies Are Worth Investing In?

I’ve wasted money on fancy seed-starting gadgets I didn’t really need, but I’ve also found some game-changing tools that make the process easier.

My must-haves:
✅ Seed trays with drainage – Avoids overwatering issues.
✅ Grow lights – Absolutely essential for strong seedlings.
✅ Heat mat – Boosts germination for heat-loving plants like tomatoes and peppers.
✅ Small fan – Helps prevent disease and strengthens stems.
✅ Soil thermometer – Ensures your soil is warm enough for germination.
✅ Spray bottle – Great for gentle watering without disturbing seedlings.

9. Keep Learning and Experimenting

Seed starting is part science, part art, and part patience. Some things will go wrong, and that’s okay! Each season, I tweak my setup based on what worked (and what didn’t) the year before.

If you’re new to seed starting, my best advice is:

Start small – Don’t overwhelm yourself with too many varieties at once.
Take notes – Keep track of what works so you can improve each year.
Be patient – Gardening is all about trial and error.

Most importantly, enjoy the process! There’s nothing quite like the feeling of growing your own food from seed to harvest.

If you’ve had any seed-starting struggles or successes, I’d love to hear about them in the comments! What’s the biggest lesson you’ve learned so far?

With love,

Bri & Cat

Affiliate Disclaimer:
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This comes at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products that we believe will add value to our readers.